Quick Answer: Why Did Dutch Shoot Micah?

Did Dutch know Micah was a rat?

No.

Dutch only realized Micah was the rat by 1907, far too late to save Arthur.

He didn’t think of the possibility that the guy who was mindlessly following him was the person telling him off..

Does Dutch regret Arthur?

Arthur was disappointed by how Dutch was acting and killing when he didn’t have too. No Dutch did not hate Arthur but he liked Micah better at the end.

Who kills Micah?

Eight years later, in 1907, Micah has formed a gang of his own. John, Sadie, and Charles later track him down at his camp. In a Mexican standoff, Dutch shoots Micah, letting John finish him off.

Why did Dutch kill himself?

He just acknowledged that he was a dying breed, and took what little choice he had left into his own hands. Based on Micah’s dialogue that “all sorts of people are making a social calls,” Dutch also just showed up.

Why did Dutch like Micah?

Micah Was The Newcomer In The Van der Linde Gang Dutch adopted both John Marston and Arthur Morgan into his gang when they were teenagers, for example, making him like a father figure to the outlaws. … Clearly Dutch felt like he owed Micah something in particular after Micah saved his life that fateful day.

Does Dutch kill Micah?

Unexpectedly, it’s Dutch that shoots Micah, despite being his partner, allowing John to get the drop on him, and then he wanders away unscathed as John thanks him, leading into what we know happens in RDR1 with that conflict reigniting itself later.

Why did Dutch leave John to die?

From what I understand, he’s basically their father, so why would he let those two die instead of the others? He was paranoid about loyalty in all the wrong ways and thought they’d betrayed him by constantly questioning his methods and decisions.

Why did Dutch hate John?

The jealousy of seeing someone else who has a family, and them choosing to neglect them, makes Dutch hate John. Arthur had a son Isaac who was killed in a home robbery .

Could Arthur have killed Micah?

No. It would’ve made the epilogue fairly pointless and unsatisfying. I also think that Arthur being killed by Micah is a fitting ending showing how brutal the life an outlaw is, along with the West in general, and symbolises Micah’s betrayal. If nothing else, at least it was a quick death.

How does Dutch die?

Lonely and upset, Dutch disappeared from the area for long years, and despite claims of sightings, was thought to have perished in a fire following a botched robbery in 1906, the robbery in which Johnwas left to die, leading him to retire from the gang. John himself thought that Dutch is in Colombia.